2010 Buffaloes defeated Master's Maintenance Bulldogs 15-12 (OT) 

2009 Buffaloes defeated Rage 13-6 (2OT) 

2008 Yellow Jackets defeated Italian Village/Stax 20-12 

2007 Hood defeated Buffaloes 18-6 

2006 Stax brunch and Lunch defeated Willow House Buffaloes 26-6 

2005 Rookies Sports Bar defeated Willow House Buffaloes 13-6

2004 Rookies Sports Bar defeated Penn Hotel 13-6

2003 Buffaloes defeated Angie's Brookside 20-6

2002 Windsor defeated Buffaloes 12-7

2001 Stax Outlaws defeated Buffaloes 47-32

2000 Buffaloes defeated Cuse 31-7

1999 Wildcats defeated Buffaloes 13-12

1998 Wildcats defeated Stax 36-24

1997 Green Machine

1996 Green Machine